Maccomo's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[My Breath Upon Your Hand]

Nice!!!

I just really like the sound of piano...But the quality of the guitar and vocals or not so good...Nice! I enjoyed it.

Go check out my new song "Sunder".

LLAAPPSSEE responds:

Those are strings my friend! One of the few entries of mine that use no piano.

[--modern minimalism--]

Soft and gentle.

I enjoyed this, and this is not crap^^. I like it. I like playing stuff like that on my piano. And actually now i made a song out of it. Well, nice work. Keep it up!

riemannSum responds:

Haha, well thanks alot. I felt that this came across exactly how I wanted it too (the other editions didn't really pan out like this one did). This was the original and I had to change for the others.

I appreciate the support and I surely will keep it up :)

[Binary Rain]

Enjoyed it...

This really is a nice soft and gentle tune. 5/5 I like it especially now when i just had a week of solid rain. I actually made something similar, well rain gives you ideas^^

The thunder and rain fits really well.

Anima-Theory responds:

Thanks for the review :D

Anima

[The Doll]

Nice...

I enjoyed this one alot, it makes me think of clouds going away and the sun comming out. (Well, maybe this is the only thing i can think of right now, when i had a week of rain^^)

It's a bit short thought, this song could be even better if it were a bit longer.

vai90 responds:

It is indeed short overall, but that was what I was going for, a short but sweet little melody.^^

Thx for the review!

[++ Kaim Reborn ++]

I really enjoyed this.

I listened to all of your songs now, and i must say they all were really great. I really liked this song aswell, soft and gentle... But i didn't like the drums that much, i liked the cymbal's otherwise it made your song sound like marching music. Please change those drums to something else. Everythings so gentle and soft and then suddendly come those drums and i think im marching in the army.

But other than that, great work. All of your songs. Well i added you as fav artist^^

kelwynshade responds:

The drums are to remind the main character Kaim of his past, where he's spent many many years as a mercenary. The drums make sense if you've played the game.

I'm glad you like it regardless.

[Sacred]

Great!

This really gives me that kind of feeling... This could also be well used in some kind of "sacred" flash game. And about the human voice, i just realised you are right^^

Go check out my new song "Sunder".

Cpt-Nemo responds:

I'm glad you liked it. Thanks for the review.

I checked out your track and I must say that I enjoyed it, but in the future please don't leave bumps for your own music as a review. I'm more than happy to check out someone else's music who has taken the time to listen to mine. Please just send a message instead.

[E.F. - Afghan (Boss Battle)]

I need that game. NOW!

Man this is so awesome, I wan't to kill that Boss, but i found myself listening to this Music while playing AOE.

I thought this will be really anoying and repetiive with time, but actually it didn't get boring(ok, maybe that's just me^^)

But if i make any flashGame i'll be sure too look you up.

kelwynshade responds:

Awesome, thanks man.

Definitely keep me in mind if you want custom Flash Game music. I'm always willing to do some work.

[Stream]

Nice...

I like it, but a bit a lack of quality.

Just please explain me this.
I'm the second to vote and i voted 4/10, then it told me 4.00 / 5.00 (- 0.0000090)
WTH? It was 4, and i voted 4 so i put your score down(- 0.0000090)???
lol

Wistfane responds:

I m not moses i have no idea mate maybe they are out to get me.... but yes i apologise for the lack of sound quality as i said i ll try to get logic pro coz it will make it all better

[Nocturne no. 2 Andante dolce]

It's real nice...

I like it, soft, happy, and sad. I ussually like to invent and improvise over such things.
But i never make a song out of my things...Well now i'm going to, go check it out when im finished :)

But u recorded this?, cause it sometimes lacks quality...

MusicalRocky responds:

That's cool! I'll try to remember to check it out whenever you're done ;)
Yeah, I recorded it, but it's still a computer playing; it's Garritan's Steinway Grand though. I don't know what you mean by lacking quality...

Anyway thanks!

EDIT: I see now that you meant the recording peaked a bit. That's cause of me recording it live off of Noteworthy, and because of my lack of knowledge on how to control that. (I don't even think you really can control peaking in Garritan Studio.) Anyway I hope this renewed mp3 peaks less; seems to do so to me :D

-Rocky

[Experiment #2]

Pretty good.

Would be an awesome loop, but as a song I think it should have some more melodies and maybe a breakdownpart.

Else this is Great.

Check out my new Song.
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/liste n/135785
(remove the space)

SkatingIsGenetic responds:

Thanks for the review!

I'll be sure to check out your song.